How to Choose an accountant

Choosing the right accountant is an important decision. You need someone who understands your business, communicates clearly, offers proactive advice and provides fair, transparent fees. Most importantly, you should feel comfortable with them and be able to trust their advice.

Below is a simple checklist to help you choose the right accountant and get the best value from the relationship.

Communication and Accessibility
Choose an accountant you can contact whenever you need help or advice, without worrying about being charged for every phone call or email. They should communicate clearly, speak in plain English and be easy to understand. Good accountants listen carefully, not just talk at you.

Ask whether they use email and online tools, as this speeds up service and keeps costs down.

Understanding Your Business
Your accountant should take a genuine interest in your business and understand how it works. Talk to them about your ideas and plans and see how commercially aware they are. A good accountant should offer practical business advice, not just report historical figures.

They should also be willing to visit your business for an initial consultation, ideally free of charge, so they can understand your operations properly.

Proactive Tax and Business Advice
Ask what tax ideas they already have for you. The right accountant will offer proactive tax planning and regularly suggest ways to reduce your tax bill legally.

They should prepare properly for meetings and focus on helping you shape your future, not just deal with past compliance.

Fees, Value and Transparency
Wherever possible, agree a fixed fee in advance so you know exactly what you will pay. If work cannot be fixed-priced, ask for a fee cap that won’t be exceeded without your agreement.

Don’t focus only on hourly rates. What matters most is the value you receive. More experienced accountants often work faster and more efficiently, saving you money overall.

Service Levels and Reliability
Ask about guaranteed timescales for completing work and how quickly they respond to calls and emails. A quick response now is a good indicator of future service levels.

Find out who you will actually be dealing with. Will you have a consistent point of contact or be passed between different people?

Services and Future Needs
Make sure the accountant offers all the services you need now and may need in the future, such as bookkeeping, payroll, tax planning, business advice and compliance services.

Review their website to see how proactive they appear and what they offer their clients. A professional website often reflects a professional service.

Reputation and Trust
Ask to speak to existing clients or read testimonials to see what others say about their service.

Request a copy of their engagement letter and make sure it clearly sets out everything they will do for you.

Final Tip: Do They Listen and Take Action?
The right accountant will listen to your concerns, take a real interest in your business and act on what you need. If they don’t, move on quickly.

Our Core Services

Bookkeeping
Stressed out with paperwork? Let Butterworths Accountants take it off your hands. Simply drop off your invoices, bank statements and records, and we will take care of all the processing for you.
Making Tax Digital for Income Tax
From 6 April 2026, the major change under Making Tax Digital (MTD) for Income Tax Self-Assessment (MTD for ITSA) comes into effect in the UK. This is a significant update to how certain self-employed individuals and landlords report their income to HMRC.
Business start-up
Starting a business is a really exciting time, but we know it is also a very busy time. You will no doubt have your plans in place and the drive to succeed, but you may not be aware of all the financial aspects involved.
Accounting
Butterworths can help reduce the time you spend on admin work, letting you focus on what is really important to your business.
VAT
Value Added Tax (VAT) is a tax that must be paid when purchasing services or goods. At Butterworths we can help you through the whole VAT process, including:
Payroll
Worried about a PAYE inspection? Butterworths Accountants’ PAYE Healthcheck service is designed to identify PAYE issues before HMRC does.
Tax
Need help with your tax return or want to pay less tax? Butterworths Accountants provide personal tax services for both business owners and private individuals.